policy

Labor Dept. Warns Employers Over Inaccurate Health Plan Provider Directories

Summarized from DOL News Releases and Briefs

A federal survey found 36% of provider directory listings were wrong, exposing workers to surprise out-of-network costs and care delays.

Labor Dept. Warns Employers Over Inaccurate Health Plan Provider Directories

The U.S. Department of Labor on Thursday issued an enforcement alert directing employers and health plan fiduciaries to ensure provider directories are accurate and regularly updated, citing widespread errors that can saddle workers with unexpected medical bills.

An undercover survey by the department's Employee Benefits Security Administration revealed the scale of the problem: agency staff called more than 27,000 providers across 27 networks and found that more than one-third of directory listings contained incorrect information. The errors ranged from listing physicians as in-network when they were not, to outdated contact details that made it impossible to schedule appointments.

Read more Fed Releases Bank Survey on Reserve Balance Management Strategies →

The department also introduced a "pathway to service" metric measuring whether a listed provider could be reached, confirmed as in-network, and seen by a new patient within 30 days. By that standard, 66% of medical and surgical providers fell short, while 74% of mental health and substance use disorder providers failed to meet all three criteria — a gap federal officials called particularly troubling given ongoing demand for behavioral health services.

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and the No Surprises Act, health plans and insurers are already legally obligated to maintain current provider directories. The new alert outlines best practices, clarifies fiduciary responsibilities, and provides a list of questions employers should pose to their plan service providers to verify that directories are being properly maintained. Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling said plans and insurers "must do better" to allow workers and their families to make informed care decisions.

Employers and workers seeking assistance with private-sector health or retirement plans can contact EBSA at askebsa.dol.gov or by calling 866-444-3272 toll-free. Continue reading at DOL News Releases and Briefs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.What did the Labor Department's secret shopper survey find about provider directories?

EBSA staff called more than 27,000 providers across 27 networks and found that 36% of provider directory information was incorrect, including doctors listed as in-network who were not.

Q.What is the 'pathway to service' metric the DOL introduced?

The metric evaluates whether a listed provider can be contacted, confirmed as in-network, and is accepting new patients within 30 days. Sixty-six percent of medical and surgical providers and 74% of mental health providers failed to meet all three criteria.

Q.What laws require health plans to keep provider directories accurate?

Health plans and insurance issuers are required under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and the No Surprises Act to regularly verify, update, and publish accurate provider directory information.

More in policy →