U.S. Loyalty Programs Draw Investment but Fall Short of Expectations
Businesses are boosting loyalty program spending, but a new study shows most consumers feel their rewards rarely exceed expectations.
American businesses are ramping up investment in customer loyalty programs even as new research signals a persistent gap between what consumers expect and what those programs actually deliver, according to a study released by arrivia.
The research found that 90% of U.S. consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization. Yet only 32% say their rewards program consistently exceeds expectations — a stark disconnect that suggests increased spending alone may not be sufficient to satisfy a demanding customer base.
Read more Huawei Showcases AI Scalability Tools for Banks at Singapore FinTech Fest →
The findings point to a growing pressure on companies to rethink how loyalty programs are structured, moving beyond basic point accumulation toward experiences and benefits that genuinely resonate with members. The gap between enrollment and satisfaction has become a central challenge for brands competing for long-term consumer relationships.
Arrivia, a Scottsdale, Arizona-based loyalty and travel rewards platform, conducted the research as organizations across retail, financial services, and travel prepare budget allocations heading into 2027. The data suggests that simply maintaining or expanding a program is not enough — the quality and relevance of rewards are becoming the decisive factors in whether a consumer stays engaged.
For brands, the takeaway is clear: investment must be paired with a sharper focus on delivering value that consumers actually notice and appreciate, or increased spending risks yielding diminishing returns in customer retention. Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.